Campaigns
Stolen Assets
Duvalier
According to estimates of Transparency International and the UN, Jean-Claude
Duvalier (Baby-Doc) embezzled between $300m and $1.2bn during his regime
(1972-1986). He was able to empty most of his Swiss accounts in time
after his ousting. However, $7m were found on Swiss bank accounts.
On February 12, 2008 the Swiss authorities decided to repatriate the
funds to the Haitian government. International and Swiss NGO played
a central role in the prolongation of the freezing-in of the funds
in 2007 and are in touch with the Haitian NGO and the Swiss government
concerning the issues of repatriation, use and monitoring.
Mobutu
Joseph-Désiré Mobutu reigned from 1965-1997. In the last
year of his dictatorship, he managed to transfer most of his Swiss funds
to foreign accounts. The Swiss Banking Commission reported no more than
9m CHF Mobutu-funds on Swiss accounts in 1997. The following procedure
of mutual legal assistance, like in the Duvalier case, was hampered by
political loyalties. In 2008 AFP took initiative and leadership in mobilizing
Congolese NGO and lobbying the Swiss authorities. Only on December 12,
2008, after heavy public pressure and intensive lobbying in Kinshasa,
did the Democratic Republic of Congo mandate a lawyer to request the
repatriation to the Congolese government.
Abacha
After dictator Sani Abacha's death in 1999, $500m embezzled funds were
found on Swiss accounts. In 2004, a delegation of Swiss NGO attended
the founding conference of the Nigerian NGO Network on Stolen Assets
comprising 50 NGO from all 6 geopolitical regions. Upon intensive media
work and lobbying of Swiss NGO on the premises and back in Switzerland,
for the first time, the Swiss government used its full diplomatic leeway
and negotiated with Nigeria about the use of the funds as well as the
monitoring of the use. In September 2005, Nigeria agreed with Switzerland
and the World Bank that the latter should organise a monitoring exercise
for 50 projects, providing that 10 Nigerian government representatives
and 10 NGO-representatives would report the degree of project implementation
on the premises and in the books. In spring 2006, the monitoring was
done and in December of the same year the World Bank and the NGO released
two separate reports. The findings were that many projects had been
accomplished before the funds were repatriated, or that they had been
abandoned or poorly implemented. Despite these sore results, the monitoring
exercise as such was a very important achievement in the repatriation
of stolen assets.
[more, PEMFAR
SHADOW REPOR pdf 545KB, www.go.worldbank.org]
Angola
Anti-corruption organizations Aktion Finanzplatz Schweiz (AFP), Berne
Declaration and Global Witness have been calling in vain on the Public
Prosecutor and the Investigating Judge of Geneva to take action in
a criminal investigation pending since 2000 into alleged corruption
that involves significant public funds and key political figures in
Angola, one of Africa’s major oil producers. The case concerns
hundreds of millions of dollars of suspicious transactions through
a bank account in Geneva at the end of the 1990s.
[more, Geneva
Prosecutor must revive Angola Oil Corruption Probe pdf 17KB]
Illegitimate Debts (odious debts)
In recent years, the doctrine of odious debts has become
a new tool in the hands of debt activists. It is estimated that $ 500
billion’s
worth of loans of developing countries could be regarded as odious as
they have mostly been contracted by dictators or odious regimes. But
the concept of odious debts arguably can be extended and can deepen a
new approach to sustainable loans to Third World Country, freeing money
for a more just and democratic development in the Third World. Aktion
Finanzplatz Schweiz documented the discussion on odious debts in the
last few years, producing several highly regarded publications in German.
In 2005 AFP published a new brochure on “Odious debts – human
rights and indebtness”, containing papers by leading exponents
in the field, including Charles Abrahams (South Africa), Damien Millet
(France), Beverley Keene (Buenos Aires) and David Ugolor (Nigeria). On
October 3 and 4 2007 AFP organized an International Conference on Illegitimate
Debts in Bern, Switzerland. For the first time legal experts and civil
society representatives met to discuss the possibilities of applying
the concept of odious debts in international law and in private law.
Papers of the International Conference on Illegitimate Debts (Odious
Debts)
in Bern, Switzerland, October 3/4 2007
Conference reports
Case studies:
-
Favorable conjuncture on the global market and conservative
debt policy. Azerbaijan case study, Ingilab Agajan Ahmadov, Director of the «Public
Finance Monitoring Center» in Azerbaijan [pdf
194 KB]
-
Argentina 1976 – 2007:The paradigmatic case of an extraordinarily
legitimate debt, Beverly Keene, Dialogue 2000 Argentina, Jubilee
South/Americas [pdf
147 KB]
-
Présentation du cas de la République
Démocratique
du Congo, Victor Nzuzi Mbembe, Member of the farmers
organization GRAPR and of NAD in DRC [ pdf
FR 106 KB]
- Drop Pakistan Debt: There is no other way, Farooq Tariq, Campaign for
the cancellation of third world debt (CADTM), Pakistan [pdf
93 KB]
Key note speaches:
- Alternatives to the traditional odious debts
doctrine, Sabine Michalowski,
Reader in Law, University of Essex [pdf
109 KB]
-
The Dilemma of Odious Debts, Mitu Gulati, professor at the law faculty
of the Duke University in Durham, North Carolina, USA [pdf
65 KB]
Other conference papers:
- NGO activities on illegitimate debts in Europe,
Jürgen
Kaiser, erlassjahr, Germany [pdf
95 KB]
- A Fresh Look at the Odious Debt Doctrine (part
of the AFP brochure “Odious
debts – human rights and indebtness”), Charles Abrahams,
South Africa, attorney and legal adviser of the NGO coalition Jubilee
South Africa and legal representative of the Apartheid, Debt & Reparations
Campaign [pdf
163 KB]
-
Odious Debts in International and Private Law [fpi 2/07], André Rothenbühler,
Aktion Finanzplatz Schweiz [pdf
99 KB]
Different papers on odious debts
- Lis Füglister: Odious debt – human rights
and debt cancellation [pdf
91 KB]
- Lis Füglister: Campaigns and activities [pdf
64 KB]
- Beverly Keene: Haiti needs freedom from
debt, now! [pdf 79 KB]
- African Jubilee South on the G7 Finance
Ministers Debt Cancellation Announcement; Jubilee South Reiterates
Demand for 100% Unconditional
Cancellation [pdf 25 KB]
- Eric Toussaint: The odious debt of Russia,
the new Oligarchs and the Bretton Woods institutions [pdf
115 KB]
Tax avoidance
Aktion Finanzplatz is a member of the international Tax Justice Network
and supports its aim of a more just tax system and its fight against
tax fraud and capital flight Aggressive tax avoidance. A new issue in the context
of corporate social responsibility. Lecture by André Rothenbühler,
October 2005 [pdf
87 KB]
For further information see also: www.taxjustice.net
South Africa
Aktion Finanzplatz supports the aim of the Khulumani court case against
multinational corporations for compensation to victims of the apartheid
regime, and in looking to extend the accountability to multinationals
Amicus curiae in support of Khulumani, September 2004 [pdf
5.21 MB (60 pages)]
Press release Khulumani, September 2004 [pdf
300 KB]
For further information see: www.apartheid-reparations.ch
|
|